The Argument From Design: Its Issues and the Issues with the Issues
Introducing the Argument from Design: Suppose you are in the desert and you find a watch on the ground. Immediately you know, a posteriori, that the watch, with its evident complexity, had a designer. Analogously, the universe and the life within it is more intricate than the watch. Therefore, the best explanation for its intricacy is an intelligent designer (some call this God). This is William Paley’s version of the argument from design (Tennant). Criticisms and Attacks on the Argument from Design from Naturalism. The contemporary naturalist criticizes the argument from design because the naturalists have a better theory to explain the appearance of design in nature. This ‘better’ theory is the New Synthesis: the classical Darwinian model fused with modern genetics. This theory shows how apparent ‘design’ in living organisms could have arisen blindly, through mutations and natural selection, without the need for a sentient d esigner . If this is true, Paley’s w atchmaker w...